1 2 3 4 5

Three signs your messaging strategy needs help

Filed in Messaging Strategy

Kevin Smith

Kevin Smith brings 30 years of experience in research and brand strategy to his role as strategy director at Riggs Partners. He has advised mission-driven companies, state agencies and nonprofits in designing communications that leverage purpose to drive consumer action. Kevin serves as lead principal of For Goodness Sakes, Riggs Partners’ behavioral science practice, helping organizations harness these scientific principles to shape communications and inspire positive behavior. He shares his perspective through widely followed insights on behavioral science and social impact.

I’m not handy. I wish it were different, but no amount of renovation-based television programming or YouTube videos seems to change things. I can be stymied by the simplest of repairs, so much so that I’ve found it less awkward to hire someone at the outset rather than engage them after I’ve botched things up on my own. I’ve seen the cause marketing equivalent of my conundrum often enough that I’ve decided to share a few common signals that your endeavor may outstrip your current capabilities.


1. There is no metric for success.

Most of the issues we’re working to address don’t have awareness problems. Not only do we know the problems, but we also usually understand the root causes. General awareness building is not only passive but also passé. Acquiring new donors is becoming increasingly difficult, making donor retention a critical strategy for 2025. Impact reporting and transparency play key roles in building trust and enhancing donor engagement. This is especially true when it comes to your organization’s next generation of donors.

2. Your audience doesn’t have a clear first step.

Your goal should be to spark the first action toward the change you seek. Too many messages try to rush a wholesale transformation. This is where the most errors occur, and the culprit is money. Public education campaigns are expensive, so nonprofits and foundations try to accomplish everything at once. But large-scale changes can only begin after identifying an easy and early win for the people you are trying to help. My go-to strategy is one that’s testable without commitment. Examples include a simple online questionnaire that provides recommendations or video testimonials offering a preview of a would-be beneficiary’s experience.

3. Your message is no surprise.

There are many hurdles between beneficiaries and behavioral change. Being told your program is “good” for them isn’t enough. Being told their behavior is “bad” for them is even worse. People look away from negative messages that restate what they already know. The more obvious your message, the greater the need to tell it differently. Unexpected messengers are a classic tactic, as is humor.

I was recently reminded of one of the most successful PSAs ever, Dumb Ways to Die. Using a humorous approach to a deadly issue prompted 27 million people to sign a train safety pledge. Of all things, the campaign is anchored by a jingle that chronicles a series of outrageous scenarios, from poking a grizzly bear with a stick to taking off one’s helmet in outer space. (The one that resonated most with me? Doing my own electrical work.) Online games and children’s books were part of an overall content program that drove a 20% drop in incidents.


If your messages exhibit any of the above symptoms, it’s a good time to reassess things. Just because you can handle your cause’s comms doesn’t mean you’re getting all you should out of them. At the same time, let me acknowledge that sometimes there are budget realities that prevent hiring an expert. But when it’s a little painful but not impossible, the results usually prove the investment a wise one.

Hiring a specialist can avoid the sunk-cost fallacy that accompanies “the way we’ve always done things.” It also saves time and makes decision-making less risky. There are exceptions of course, like last week’s guest on “The Science of Good,” Invisible People’s CEO and documentarian, Mark Horvath. Yet for the cause leader who wants greater impact, you’re welcome to borrow my mantra: Having a hammer doesn’t make you a carpenter.



Featured Posts